The right tortilla can make or break your quesadilla, burrito, or taco. If you’ve ever seen tons of tortillas at the store, you might have wondered which one is the best.
In some cases, the brand may not matter. But you don’t want to use a brand that will make your next Mexican dish tasteless and limp.
What Are the Best Tortilla Brands?
Some of the best brands of tortillas include Mission, Old El Paso, and 365. Other brands to try include Silva’s, Mi Rancho, and Market Pantry. If possible, you might also want to buy tortillas from a local Mexican bakery so they’re fresh.
Be sure to consider all of the size, grit, and other characteristics. This way you can choose the best tortilla for you.
Best Tortilla Brands
There are dozens of tortilla brands and flavors to choose from. Next time you want to make tacos or burritos, consider the following options.
Then you can make sure you choose the brand you like the most.
mission
Mission makes some of the best tortillas for tacos and other Mexican dishes. Of course they make standard flour tortillas, but they also make carb balance and zero net carb tortillas if you count your carbs.
You can also find whole wheat, spinach herb, and tomato basil tortillas. These might not be the most authentic, but you can use them to make a lunch wrap. The tortillas also come in different sizes so you can get small ones for tacos or big ones for burritos.
Old El Paso
Old El Paso is another popular brand when it comes to Mexican food. You can purchase their restaurant-style tortillas to make a meal similar to what you would get at your favorite Mexican eatery. They also make smaller flour tortillas that are perfect for tacos.
If you don’t want food to escape, you can even buy food bags. They’re not that authentic, but you can stuff them with fillings and eat them however you like. You can even buy a fajita dinner kit that includes standard tortillas.
365
When you shop at Whole Foods, you get the 365 brand of tortillas. They make flour tortillas, corn tortillas, and a mix of flour and corn. You can even find whole wheat tortillas, which are great for making sandwich wraps.
Of course, since Amazon is owned by Whole Foods, you can also buy all of these varieties from the online shopping site. This way you can order them no matter where you live. You can use the tortillas in a variety of dishes.
Silvas
Kansas City residents and tourists can also purchase Silva’s tortillas. The brand focuses on producing traditional Mexican ingredients and foods. You can buy both small and large tortillas, so you can get the perfect size for a quesadilla, taco, or anything in between.
Unfortunately, you can’t seem to buy the tortillas online. That means you have to visit the Midwestern city to stock up. However, they are an excellent brand for the locals as they are made locally.
Mi Rancho
Mi Rancho tortillas come in both flour and corn varieties. That means you can get the flavor you want, and gluten-free people can avoid the flour tortillas. All varieties are also organic, which can be a nice benefit.
Many of the tortillas are also kosher and you can buy them in stores or online. However, it’s unclear if they come in multiple sizes. So you may have to settle for tortillas that are slightly larger or smaller than you would like.
Market pantry
Target Market Pantry Tortillas are an excellent brand to try. If you prefer to shop for groceries at Target or their website, this is the brand for you. They make flour and whole grain options, and you can choose between six and eight inches in size.
Of course, you can’t buy this brand anywhere outside of Target. So if you don’t live close to a shop it may be less convenient. However, you can order them for delivery
Trader Joe’s
We couldn’t find a link to them online, but Trader Joe’s also sells tortillas. You can find a few options, but the exact choice will likely vary from store to store. If you can’t find the tortillas you like, they have a recipe for gluten free tortillas.
Trader Joe’s has the ingredients you need to get started. Then you can top tacos, burritos, or quesadillas with any of your favorite fillings. Trader Joe’s is usually fairly affordable, so both the ready-made and homemade options shouldn’t cost too much.
Local Bakery
Your local bakery isn’t branded, but it’s another source to consider for tortillas. If you can’t find tortillas you like, consider finding a Mexican bakery. Some sell tortillas to consumers so you can use them at home.
The beauty of this option is that they’re usually much fresher than the supermarket ones. You can enjoy them both pure and warm in a Mexican dish. Just make sure you know when they make tortillas fresh to take advantage of that proximity.
Your own
Another off-brand option is to make your own tortillas at home. Of course, you can follow a Trader Joe’s recipe. But you can also find a recipe from an authentic Mexican food blog or website.
Making tortillas can be a huge project, so it’s not for everyone. However, it’s a great way to spend your time making a good product. You can also ensure there is no gluten cross-contamination if you or a family member needs to eat gluten-free.
How do you choose the best tortillas?
When comparing some of the top tortilla brands, there are a few things to keep in mind. You might get lucky and love the first tortilla brand you find. However, you may not like it, or the tortillas will stick together and break if you try to separate them.
When buying tortillas, keep the following things in mind. Then you can increase the chances of buying a pack you like.
Start with size
Chances are, you’re looking for tortillas because you want to use them for something specific. In many cases, you also know what size you want. For example, if you want to make tacos, you will need smaller tortillas.
However, you may prefer larger tortillas for quesadillas, enchiladas, or burritos. Knowing what size you want can help narrow down your choice of brands. Some companies only have one or two size options.
You can find tortillas as small as six inches or as large as 10 inches. The size refers to the diameter, so keep that in mind when shopping.
Look at the grain
Another thing to think about is whether the tortillas are flour, corn, whole wheat, or something else. If you’re gluten-free, get corn tortillas, since flour and wheat don’t suit your dietary restriction.
But if you’re looking for a sandwich wrap, you can also check out spinach tortillas. Also think about the taste. The different grains can offer different flavors, and many people prefer one over the other.
If you can’t decide, you may be able to order a variety pack. This allows you to test a few options before committing.
Check your local options
Ordering tortillas online can be convenient. However, you will have to wait for shipping, and this process may be delayed when you receive the ingredients you need. If you want to make Mexican food tonight, you should head to your local grocery store.
You can also visit any local Mexican bakeries that sell tortillas. This way you can get what you need right away. You can even save on shipping cost and don’t have to worry about the tortillas being crushed in transit.
Sticking to local options can also limit the brand you have available. That might be a downside, but it can also help you avoid analysis paralysis so you can pick something.
Note the expiry date
The expiration date may not help you choose the best brand, but it might come down to it if your store is short on tortillas. Unless you use tortillas all the time, you should avoid any packages with an expiration date within the next month or so.
You can eat tortillas past the expiration date as long as they look and smell good. But you’ll get even more use out of tortillas if they don’t expire right after you buy them.
For this reason, you should also consider how many tortillas you get. If you live alone, you may only need a small pack. But if you have a family, buying a pack of more tortillas helps.
Final Thoughts
Some of the best tortilla brands include Mission, Old El Paso, and others. But don’t forget to visit all the local Mexican bakeries. You can also find a tortilla recipe and make it at home, which can be hard work but rewarding.
