Skip to content

The 20 Worst Salad Dressings – PreparedCooks.com

    Every salad starts with hope and ends with a dressing that's smarter than your lunch plans.

    Math teachers would shudder at the conditions in most salad bowls.

    Sometimes one pressure is equivalent to the glucose load of a slice of cake.

    You'll need a detective's magnifying glass to find anything natural on the label.

    My kale deserves better, as does my grocery list.

    1. Hidden Valley Ranch Package Mix

    from: wincofoods

    This powdered ranch dressing became America's most popular dressing in the 1970s.

    But here's the catch: One package contains over 1,000 mg of sodium.

    That's almost half the recommended daily dose in just two tablespoons.

    Many people over 50 need to pay attention to their blood pressure.

    The artificial preservatives and MSG can cause headaches in sensitive people.

    The convenience factor makes it a pantry staple, but your cardiovascular system pays the price every time you shake the package.

    2. Italian Wish Bone Dressing

    from: eatpayylove

    This food staple has been around since 1948. The original recipe contained 270 mg of sodium per serving.

    Today's version contains high fructose corn syrup as the third ingredient.

    Your body processes this differently than regular sugar.

    The artificial colors Yellow 6 and Red 40 have been linked to hyperactivity in some studies.

    The spicy taste may deceive your taste buds, but the ingredient list reads like a chemistry experiment gone wrong.

    3. Ken's Steak House chunky blue cheese

    by: kensdressings

    Ken's began in 1958 in a restaurant in Massachusetts. This thick dressing contains 150 calories per two-tablespoon serving.

    The chunky consistency comes from real blue cheese. But the base uses soybean oil as the main ingredient.

    Soybean oil is highly processed and contains omega-6 fatty acids, which can promote inflammation.

    Restaurant-quality taste comes with restaurant-sized calorie portions that can derail any healthy eating plan.

    4. Kraft Catalina dressing

    from: itskekes4me

    This sweet French-style dressing was introduced in 1962. Two tablespoons contain 12 grams of sugar.

    That's the equivalent of three teaspoons of sugar on your salad. The bright red color is created by artificial dyes.

    The tomato paste provides some lycopene. However, the sugar content overshadows any nutritional benefits.

    Your salad becomes a delivery system for liquid candy with a side of artificial colors.

    5. Marie's Caesar

    from: mariesdressing

    Marie's refrigerated dressings feel premium compared to shelf-stable options. This Caesar contains raw eggs and anchovies for an authentic taste.

    But one serving provides 170 calories and 18 grams of fat. The sodium content reaches 350 mg per serving.

    Due to the thick consistency, more than the recommended serving size is often used.

    The rich flavor that makes Caesar salad irresistible also makes it one of the most powerful ways to season your vegetables.

    6. Western Family Thousand Island

    This budget-friendly brand replicates the classic Thousand Island recipe. The pink color comes from the combination of ketchup and mayonnaise.

    Each serving contains 11 grams of sugar and 140 calories. The sweet cucumber relish adds unnecessary sodium.

    Store brands often use lower quality oils to keep costs down. This affects both taste and nutrition.

    Saving money at the supermarket can be costly later when cheap ingredients provide maximum calories with minimal nutritional value.

    7. Kraft Zesty Italian

    by: butterfieldandvallis

    Kraft's Spicy Italian Dressing contains no real Italian ingredients. The “spicy” taste comes from garlic powder and onion flakes.

    Water is the first ingredient, followed by vinegar and soybean oil. The artificial flavors create the herbal taste.

    One serving provides 70 calories but no vitamins or minerals. Rather prepare fresh Italian vinaigrette.

    The word “savory” on the label can’t hide the fact that you’re paying top dollar for flavored oil and water.

    8. Hidden Valley Original Ranch Bottled

    by: littlelondon_gh

    The bottle version differs significantly from the package mix. Eggs and buttermilk are included for creaminess.

    But it also contains modified food starch and natural flavors. The shelf-stable formula requires more preservatives.

    Two tablespoons provide 140 calories and 14 grams of fat. That's more fat than a tablespoon of butter.

    The convenience of a grab-and-go ranch comes with hidden costs that your waistline will definitely notice over time.

    9. Wish-Bone Deluxe French

    by: anandlowprice

    This sweet orange dressing became popular in the 1950s. The color comes from peppers and artificial colors.

    Sugar appears twice in the ingredients list – as regular sugar and as high fructose corn syrup. The total sugar content reaches 11 grams per serving.

    The thick consistency and sweet taste completely mask the taste of fresh vegetables.

    The name “Deluxe” suggests luxury, but the double sugar formula delivers anything but premium nutrients for your salad.

    10. Ken's Steak House Caesar

    by: kensdressings

    Ken's Caesar promises restaurant quality in a bottle. Anchovies and Parmesan provide authentic umami taste.

    However, one serving contains 150 calories and 16 grams of fat. The sodium content reaches 320 mg per two tablespoons.

    The creamy consistency is created by egg yolk and plenty of oil. I made a classic mistake and thought “restaurant quality” meant “healthier.”

    Preparing it restaurant-style at home means you can enjoy all the indulgence without there being a special occasion.

    11. Power creamy poppy seeds

    by: tchaiwellbeing

    This sweet dressing became very popular alongside spinach salads in the 1980s. The tiny black seeds provide a nutty crunch.

    But the creamy base contains 130 calories per serving. High fructose corn syrup makes it sweeter than many dessert ingredients.

    Despite their exotic appearance, poppy seeds offer minimal nutritional value. Rather, sprinkle real seeds on a lighter dressing.

    The noble appearance of poppy seeds cannot hide the fact that this dressing belongs more in the dessert department.

    12. Marie's Coleslaw Dressing

    from: mariesdressing

    This thick, creamy dressing is aimed specifically at coleslaw lovers. The mayonnaise base provides the well-known spicy-sweet taste.

    One serving provides 120 calories and contains both sugar and high fructose corn syrup. The sodium content is 200 mg per two tablespoons.

    The thick consistency encourages intensive use. Most people use twice the recommended serving size for shredded cabbage.

    What starts as a healthy cabbage salad quickly turns into a mayonnaise delivery system with vegetables on the side.

    13. Ken's Steak House Honey Mustard

    by: inhandreviews

    This popular restaurant-style dressing combines sweet honey with spicy mustard flavor. The golden color comes from turmeric and natural honey.

    Each serving contains 130 calories and 11 grams of sugar per two tablespoons. In addition to honey, the ingredients list also includes high fructose corn syrup.

    Due to the thick consistency, most people use more than the recommended serving size. This doubles the sugar and calorie load of your salad.

    The restaurant-quality flavor masks the fact that you're essentially drizzling liquid candy with a touch of mustard on your veggies.

    14. Kraft Creamy French

    This orange dressing became an American classic, even though it had no connection to France. The sweet tomato taste appeals to children and adults.

    Two tablespoons contain 120 calories and 11 grams of sugar. The artificial orange color comes from the dyes Yellow 6 and Red 40.

    The creamy texture completely hides the vegetables. Here's the deal: You're essentially pouring liquid candy onto fresh vegetables.

    The patriotic appeal of this American invention cannot disguise the fact that it turns any salad into a dessert.

    15. Hidden Valley Bacon Ranch

    by: Tami Dunn

    This flavor combination is aimed at bacon lovers looking for convenience. Real bacon bits add smoky flavor and protein.

    But the basic ranch recipe still contains 140 calories per serving. The bacon adds extra sodium on top of the already high sodium content.

    Processed bacon bits contain nitrates and preservatives. Fresh bacon crumbles would provide better flavor and fewer chemicals.

    Bacon's smoky flavor can't offset its processed ranch base, which delivers more chemicals than nutrients.

    16. Wish-Bone Russian Dressing

    by: Jason Callan

    This pink dressing is similar to Thousand Island but contains different spices. The base of mayonnaise and ketchup provides the characteristic color.

    Each serving provides 110 calories and 10 grams of sugar. The thick consistency sticks strongly to lettuce leaves.

    Russian dressing traditionally contained caviar. This version instead uses artificial flavors to mimic the complex flavor profile.

    The exotic name suggests international sophistication, but the ingredient list betrays basic American processed foods.

    17. Ken's Lite Caesar

    by: kensdressings

    This “lighter” version promises Caesar flavor with fewer calories. The label shows 70 calories instead of the regular 150.

    However, the sodium content remains high at 300 mg per serving. Artificial thickeners replace some of the oil and egg content.

    The Lite version sacrifices authentic taste in favor of reducing calories. Should I be honest? It tastes like watered down Caesar.

    The promise of fewer calories comes with the cost of artificial ingredients that create texture without delivering flavor.

    18. Marie's Chunky Roquefort

    from: mariesdressing

    This premium blue cheese dressing contains real Roquefort imported from France. The pieces provide an authentic, spicy taste.

    However, two tablespoons contain 160 calories and 17 grams of fat. That's more calories than a small chocolate bar.

    The creamy base consists of soybean oil and contains natural flavors. Real Roquefort is diluted with processed ingredients.

    Even authentic French cheese can't enhance a dressing if it's swimming in processed oils and artificial thickeners.

    19. Kraft Catalina Lite

    This reduced calorie version halves the calories of regular Catalina. The sweet tomato flavor is largely retained.

    But it still contains 8 grams of sugar per serving. High fructose corn syrup appears in the first five ingredients.

    The Lite formula uses artificial thickeners and gums. These add texture without adding any beneficial nutrients or real flavor.

    The “Lite” label allows you to use more, but the sugar content ensures you’re still adding sweetness to your greens.

    20. Hidden Valley Fiesta Ranch

    by: The Kneady Homesteader

    This Southwestern-flavored ranch adds jalapeño and tomato chunks. The colorful mixture looks fresh and appealing in the bottle.

    The vegetable pieces offer minimal nutritional value compared to fresh alternatives. The sodium content reaches 280 mg per two tablespoon serving.

    The ranch base remains unchanged from the original high-calorie formula. The added vegetables do not compensate for the processed base.

    The festive name and colorful vegetables create an illusion of freshness that is quickly destroyed by the processed ranch base.