Firefighters from Highland Beach, Fla., On the way to a conference in Miami; A money manager was on his way to his office in Boca Raton. Families with young children who wore Mickey Mouse-ears and small mermaid backpacks decreased, the sun-drenched sideways of the train on their way to or from Disney Cruises and various theme parks.
Florida, of all places, has restarted Intercity Passenger Spoorreizen in America. In the late 19th century, the Olarycoon Henry Flagler built a railway along the Atlantic coast of the state that accelerated the growth of Florida and put cities such as Miami and Palm Beach on the map. Then the car prolified.
Now is a private service called Brightline, which operates on the old line of Flagler, a 21st-century pitch for the permanent virtues of train journeys, which passen by passengers 235 miles between Miami and Orlando, with a few stops in between and hopes to reach Tampa.
The company also pursues a second service: a $ 12.4 billion, 218-mile, fully electric train that connects Las Vegas with Los Angeles, or rather, Rancho Cucamonga, California, where riders can connect to the California Metrolink to LA, it is meant to be the first high-speed-rails of America. The project, unlike in Florida, whose construction costs have been paid by Brightline, has received $ 3 billion in promised federal subsidies. The hope of the company was to serve before the 2028 Olympic Games in LA, the goal now, according to Brightline officials, is the end of 2028.
Is a private company with intercity train trips that struggles in America, the solution? It is a truth that trains are powerful engines of urban and economic development. But can they earn money?
These questions arise when the Trump administration focuses on public services such as Amtrak and the metropolitan transport authority of New York, which threatens to draw federal financing. A potential disaster for millions of American commuters, and the economies they support, the threat also creates a chance for private railways to organize a comeback.
During the mid-19th century, three private companies, which operate migrant work, completed the first transcontinental railway in six years, the 19th-century equivalent of a Moonshot. Private passenger rail in America puffed along for another century, until aircraft and the Interstate highway system paralyzed the company. The congress came in in the 1970s and founded Amtrak, which took over the last remaining private Intercity passenger train – the Rio Grande Zephyr between Denver and Salt Lake City – during the Reagan era.
Nowadays, Amtrak's rider has risen after years of decline, but the annual operational deficit last year was $ 700 million. The state of California has proposed a bullet train between Los Angeles and San Francisco, which is now lagging behind for years, entangled in regulatory and legal fights, and staring at a price tag north of $ 100 billion, without a clear strategy to collect the money.
Almost every public metro, commuters and intercity train, apart from the ACELA service of Amtrak between Boston and Washington, runs against a shortage. Brightline has spent hundreds of millions of dollars more than it earns, because of build-out costs, the officials say. But they predict that the service must approach “even break break” this year or next.
The company is the brainchild of Wes EDENS, the billionaire co-owner of the Milwaukee Bucks. Mr EDENS was co-founder of the Fortress Investment Group, whose acquisitions of truck rails include the Old Florida East Coast Railway from Flagler. After he met a book about Flagler's train just over ten years ago, Mr. Edens the idea for Brightline.
This was around the same time that the then governor of Florida, Rick Scott, a Republican, $ 2.4 billion rejected that the Obama government offered the state to undertake a quick passenger service between Tampa and Orlando. Mr. Scott said that the train would be too expensive to operate.
Mr Edens's private line accelerated ahead. It is crucial that the company owned its transit rights and avoided the long, expensive ownership fights that have plagued the high -speed train of California. “That was” a crucial advantage, “said Mr EDENS.
Construction began in 2014. Passengers started to board just over three years later.
The news has not all been rosy. Some Floridians have called the death train the death train because more than 100 people died over the tracks. Nevertheless, Brightline attracted three million riders in Florida last year and expects to serve four million this year, double that number by 2028. The station in Orlando, in the rental room at the airport, was opened at the end of 2023. More than a million customers have since driven the train between Orlando and Miami.
'A breeze' is how Joanna Cheng described the experience when we met one morning on the way. She and her two young children had flown from New York City to Fort Lauderdale to visit friends on their way to a gymnastics competition in Orlando. They were planning to drive, but Mrs. Cheng's reservation was canceled when her flight from New York was delayed.
On the suggestion of a foreign national in the rental car, she checked the BrightLine app. The service prices are tickets dynamic. Premium seats, with more space and meals, can be $ 300. But prices on all routes on average $ 55. Thanks to online discounts, the train was ultimately not only faster and more convenient, but cheaper than a car.
“We were lucky,” said Mrs. Cheng. “It reminds me of trains in Europe.”
That was the hope of Mr. Edens: to be compared to services such as Eurostar and Italo. It is not a high -speed train. But the company leans to customer-friendly service and good design, after he hired Skidmore, Owings and Merrill, the global architectural office, to design his impressive hub called Miamicentral and to switch Rockwell Group based in New York to design those efficient, stylish, tech-friendly cars.
Brightline is still not at the level of the most luxurious, faster European and Japanese railway lines, but it is a leap over Amtrak and most of the commuter lines that Americans drive. Whether the company is financially viable remains a subject of a lot of speculation and some damagefreude in transit circles.
Just like Flagler's Railway, Brightline is in reality not only a train, but also a real estate company. The company has built up three towers, then sold on top of Miamicentral and another next door, and also founded and then sold an apartment complex near the station in West Palm Beach. West Palm and Boca have become tree stations for high-end development along a coastal corridor that is now being maintained by Brightline.
In Las Vegas, Brightline West, as the Los Angeles-to-Vegas service is called, a new terminal on the comic where the company has bought more than 100 hectares that it is planning to develop.
“In retrospect,” Mr EDENS told me, “if I could do another thing, I would buy all the country around the stations.”
But of course, a private rail-outfit, chooses the stops and routes. It exists to benefit shareholders. Public railways serve a wide audience, including people in places where stations may not be profitable. Privatization of intercity train trips through the country instead of every public service would deprive huge parts of the country.
“We are at a time when the financing is frozen,” noted Janette Sadik-Khan, the former Transport Commissioner of New York City, “so we need as many new models of transit services as we can get. Brightline is one. It is great, not just for ending up, but for economic growth around stations.
“But,” Mrs Sadik-Khan added, “a private company does not have the same priorities or obligations as public systems.”
Mr. Edens sees future, potentially profitable opportunities for fast trains between other heavily traded pairs of cities that are now long journeys, but a pain to fly, such as Charlotte to Atlanta or Dallas to Houston. The Brightline West business plan imagines that 8.6 million of the 50 million people drive or fly between Los Angeles and Vegas a year. That should shorten travel times for passengers and reduce carbon dioxide emissions by around 325,000 tons per year, say business officials, and also make money.
.
In Florida I spoke with clear commuters who grumbled about the costs. But I didn't meet a passenger who complained about the ride. Walt Gates, beautiful in a razorback T-shirt, had flown in from Little Rock with his wife, Lydia, for a Disney cruise in Miami with their daughter and son-in-law.
I met them on Brightline to Orlando. “I have lost so many hours of my life that control the highway between Little Rock and Memphis,” said Mr. Gates.
He had a message for Mr. Edens: “We could use one in Arkansas.”
When it comes to transit and mobility, which project will your community change?
Follow New York Times Travel on Instagram And Sign up for our travel shipping newsletter To get expert tips about traveling smarter and inspiration for your next vacation. Offer a future outing or just traveling an armchair? View our 52 places to go in 2025.
The Headway Initiative is financed by subsidies from the Ford Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and the Stavros Niarchos Foundation (SNF), with Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors who serve as a tax sponsor. The Woodcock Foundation is a financier of the Public Square of Headway. Financiers have no control over the selection, focus of stories or the processing process and do not assess stories before publication. The Times retains full editorial control of the Headway initiative.
